Toasted Subs on Homemade Bread

Bread, meat, cheese, veggies, and sauce. We’re experts.

Our gourmet specialty subs are offered in 6″ & 12″ sizes made with homemade dressings, fresh sliced meats, cheeses & condiments. If you would like to add or delete items you can. Some items are an extra charge. All but 1 sub is toasted unless otherwise requested cold. Choose from four fresh, in-house baked homemade breads: Zesty Italian Parmesan & Cheddar,  Honey Wheat,  White Italian, and Wade’s Grinder Pizza Bread.

Our breads are baked fresh daily.

Sammy Blue Eyes Sub

Turkey, candied bacon, cheddar, ranch, lettuce, tomato slices.

  • new
The “Inferno” Sub

Featuring spicy smoked grilled chicken from ‘Q It Up! We got together with our friends at ‘Q It Up! and decided it was a no brainer to take two great products & combine them together to make one “Super Product.” On this submarine sandwich we put a load of ‘Q It Up! spicy, juicy chicken, Frank’s Red Hot, jalapeño peppers, black pepper, lettuce, and pepper jack cheese.

  • qitup
  • gf
Smoked Deli Ham and Mozzarella Sub

Sliced ham, mozzarella, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and mayo.

  • gf
Roast Beef Extravaganza Sub

Scrumptious combination of tender roast beef, smoked turkey, banana peppers, onions, fresh green peppers, mayo, cheddar, sliced mozzarella, crisp lettuce, and tomatoes.

  • gf
Pit Smoked BBQ Sub

Juicy pork marinated in our very own BBQ sauce, shredded then put on one of our homemade breads of your choice topped with fresh sliced provolone cheese.

  • gf
Turkey & Roast Beef Sub

Smoked turkey, tender roast beef, mozzarella, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and mayo.

Italian Sausage Sub

Yes, we make the sausage, the bread and the marinara in house. We buy the mozzarella from Wisconsin and top it with sautéed green peppers and onions.

  • gf
Veggie Style Sub

Mozzarella cheese, crisp green peppers, fresh sliced mushrooms, onions, green and black olives, fresh lettuce, sliced tomatoes, and mayo.

  • gf
  • veg
Club Sub

A traditional club sandwich with savory sliced ham, smoked turkey breast, crisp bacon, mayo, and mozzarella slices. Pick your choice of fresh baked bread, we’ll bake it and top it off with lettuce and tomato.

  • gf
The Eight Dollar Sub

It’s got it all! Sliced smoked deli ham, oven-roasted turkey breast, premium roast beef, Genoa salami, black olives, green olives, fresh mushrooms, crunchy green peppers, white onions, banana peppers, provolone and mozzarella cheese, mayo, crisp lettuce, and tomatoes on a fresh baked bread of your choice.

Tri Tip Steak, Candied Bacon, Sweet Baby Rays Sub

‘Q It Up! tri tip, candied bacon, cheddar, butter, Sweet Baby Rays, lettuce.

  • new
  • qitup
Classic B.L.T. Sub

Crisp applewood smoked bacon, mayo, mozzarella, fresh crisp lettuce, and tomatoes. Always a tasty American favorite.

Traditional Pizza Sub

Loaded with full-flavored pepperoni, deli-sliced ham, mozzarella, fresh mushrooms, green olives & onions topped with our very own pizza sauce. Pick your fresh baked bread and we’ll toast it to perfection for you.

  • gf
Frank’s Red Hot Sub
Marinated grilled chicken breast slathered in Frank’s Red Hot and finished off with homemade buttermilk ranch, provolone cheese, and mayo.

Make it ‘Q It Up! chicken.

  • qitup
  • gf
Roast Beef Sub

Tender premium roast beef, mozzarella, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and mayo.

The Deluxe Sub

Time tested Erbelli’s sub. It was one of the originals! Deli-style ham and Genoa salami, mozzarella cheese, fresh mushrooms, green olives, white onion, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a fresh baked bread of your choice.

  • gf
Meatball Sub

Italian-Style sliced meatballs basted with our very own fresh marinara sauce topped with mozzarella served on your choice of fresh baked bread.

Grilled Chicken Breast Sub

Grilled chicken breast, mozzarella, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce and mayo.

Make it ‘Q It Up! chicken!.

  • qitup
  • gf
The “Paul Bunyan” Sub

Tender roast beef, deli smoked ham, oven roasted turkey, mozzarella, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and mayo.

  • gf
Jimmy Two Times Cold Sub (Not Baked)

Mayo, Genoa, capicola, ham, provolone, white onion, lettuce, oil and vinegar, oregano, basil, tomato slices. COLD!!! Not baked.

  • new
The Sloaner Sub

Signature sandwich galore! We start with deli-sliced smoked turkey breast, zesty pepperoni, mayo, pepper, garlic salt, crisp green peppers, fresh red onions, provolone, and Romano cheeses topped with crispy hickory-smoked bacon.

  • gf
The “Cowlishaw” Sub

Grilled fire chicken from ‘Q It Up!, applewood flavored bacon, fresh sliced red onions, bleu cheese all topped with fresh bleu cheese crumbles toasted to perfection.

  • qitup
Classic Italian Combo Sub

One of our signature sandwiches served with Genoa salami, spicy capicola, zesty pepperoni, fresh provolone, mozzarella cheese, homemade Italian dressing, mayo, onions, crisp lettuce, and tomatoes.

  • gf
BBQ Chicken Sub

An Erbelli’s Favorite! Marinated BBQ Chicken loaded with provolone and cheddar cheese, fresh sliced red onion and mayo. Pick your favorite Erbelli’s fresh baked bread.


Smoked Turkey Breast & Deli Sliced Ham Sub

Mozzarella, turkey, ham, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and mayo.

  • gf
Smoked Turkey Breast Sub

Smoked turkey, mozzarella, tasty tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and mayo.

  • gf
Chicken Carbonara Sub

Marinated grilled chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, fresh mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes and our very own Alfredo sauce with fresh ground Romano cheese. A tasty delight!

Make it ‘Q It Up! chicken

  • gf
  • veg
The House Sub

We slice Genoa salami, spicy capicola and smoked ham and top them with fresh provolone cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

  • gf